Wednesday, March 3, 2021
Become a Patron for MCNews!
MCNews
  • NEWSLatest
  • REVIEWS
  • LATEST BIKES
  • RACING
  • FEATURES
  • TOURING
  • MEDIA
    • GALLERY
  • MORE
    • POPULAR ARTICLES
    • MCNEWS COMMENTS
    • MAIN FORUM
    • CONTACT US
    • ABOUT US
No Result
View All Result
MCNews
  • NEWSLatest
  • REVIEWS
  • LATEST BIKES
  • RACING
  • FEATURES
  • TOURING
  • MEDIA
    • GALLERY
  • MORE
    • POPULAR ARTICLES
    • MCNEWS COMMENTS
    • MAIN FORUM
    • CONTACT US
    • ABOUT US
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
MCNews

Lights on, Hi-Vis and SMIDSY

Trev by Trev
March 21, 2014
in Motorcycle News, Uncategorized
A A
Home Motorcycle News
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare

Lights on, Hi-Vis and SMIDSY – By Phil Hall

SwitchI wonder how many of my readers remember one of these?

Yes, it’s a motorcycle headlamp switch.  It allows you to select whether you want to have your headlight on or off as well as allowing you to toggle between high and low beam. Time was that every motorcycle has one, but you won’t find one fitted to a modern bike and, should you choose to fit one to your bike today (I’ll get to the reason why you might in a moment) you would be breaking the law by doing so.

Why so? Well, gentle reader, back in the dim, dark past, somebody got the brilliant (!) idea that the reason why so many motorcyclists were being killed and injured in motorcycle accidents was because other road users couldn’t see them. Fuelled by various road safety studies including the landmark Hurt Report (I always thought that the name was very apt) demands for improvement in this situation from within and without the motorcycle industry became louder and louder.

It didn’t take too long before some bright spark (!) came up with the theory that, if motorcycles had their headlights on while they were on the road, other road users would be able to see them better. After all, it was a practice for car drivers to turn their lights on at times when visibility was low, why wouldn’t it help other road users if motorcycles were more visible by having their lights on all the time?

Fast forward a little and various jurisdictions, jumping onto the road safety bandwagon, introduced legislation that required motorcycle riders to turn their headlights on while they were out on the street. “There you go,” the wise bureaucrats said, “The problem is solved. We have made motorcycling safer for riders and we can sleep soundly at night.”

Except that it didn’t quite work out like that, for all sorts of reasons. Firstly, and most significantly, motorcyclists of all manifestations, are a rebellious lot. Even mild-mannered Mr Joe Average who rode his CB175 to work because it was cheap, had, lurking inside his business suit and open face helmet, a trace of Marlon Brando, a quiet but determined feeling that he was somehow doing something daring, something anti the system, something “out there”.

“Damn them. If they want me to turn my headlights on just because they say so, I won’t. I’m not going to be dictated to by some faceless bureaucrat, I’m a motorcyclist.” Nowhere in the world did this anti-social feeling run deeper than in the USA. After all, you must understand that, at this time, the majority of states in the US didn’t even have compulsory helmet laws. This was the Home of the brave and the Land of the free.

Here in Oz, the introduction didn’t go smoothly either. Perhaps in no other country apart from America did the roots of anti-authoritarianism run deeper than in this convict-founded nation. There were huge public campaigns, rallies, stickers adorning bikes and deputations to governments at all levels. The MRA (Motorcycle Riders Association) and other lobbying bodies were mostly formed around this time and drew their support and their strength from ordinary motorcyclists who were damned if they were going to be told what to do.

So “requiring” motorcyclists to switch their headlights on while they were riding, even when backed up by a fairly rigorous campaign of police enforcement of the rule, didn’t really work.

But there were other problems, too. A lot of bikes back then (we’re talking early 70’s here, by the way) only had a six volt charging system. Running a bike with lights on while riding usually resulted in two problems. Firstly, the intensity of a six volt headlight was so weak that using it in daylight didn’t really have any positive benefit. The second problem was that doing so flattened the tiny battery and meant that the bike would not start again once you had stopped it. I well remember this being an issue with my MT125 Honda trail bike.

As well as this, most motorcycles back then were fitted with a headlight that used a normal, incandescent bulb. These were notoriously fragile and it soon emerged that, running them for extended periods, combined with the vibration to which they were subject from being mounted on a motorcycle, meant that they failed quickly and often. The legal issues associated with this phenomenon took a while to go away as well.

Perhaps the only tangible benefit (stick with me here) of the “Lights On” campaign was that manufacturers were forced to fit their bikes with more robust lighting systems. Perhaps here is another reason for the death of the British motorcycle industry?

Since time and experience showed that a “Lights On” campaign was not working and that motorcycle rider deaths and injuries were continuing to climb, the next step was obvious. When the citizenry would not comply with a “Please”, the governments replied with a “If you won’t do it voluntarily, we will MAKE you do it.”

So we come to today where, for the last 40 years or so, motorcycles are fitted with a high/low beam switch but no switch that allows the operator to turn the lights OFF. Mandating that lights HAD to be on at ALL times saw the manufacturers who wished to continue SELLING bikes in these jurisdictions , deleting the on/off switch altogether from their new models.

BUT, has the COMPULSORY “Lights On” campaign actually worked? Yes, motorcycle deaths and injuries are continuing to fall, but that is more of a consequence of improvements in inbuilt bike safety (ABS, traction control, better tyres, better brakes, etc, etc) and improvements in rider safety clothing. If you look back at the introduction of compulsory “Lights On” the initial results did look promising, but then the death and injury rate started to climb again. It is moot how much the lowering of the stats was due to the lights issue and how much of it was due to gradual safety improvements anyway.

My dad used to have a favourite analogy that aptly shows how the “Lights On” idea, though seemingly a good one at the time, was never going to work. He used to say that, if you put a frog in a saucepan of boiling water, the frog will hop out. BUT, if you put it in a saucepan of cold water and gradually heat it, the frog will stay in the pan until it is boiled to death. The concept is that it gradually accommodates itself to the increasing temperature and doesn’t realise that it is reaching fatal level until it is too late.

And so it was that, with advertising campaigns to reinforce the message, for a while motorists and other road users started noticing motorcycles. Why? Because they had their lights on and were more visible. But, after a while, because ALL motorcycles had their lights on, the initial novelty of it being so, started to fade and motorcycles started to become part of the background again. Did you get that? Yes, motorcycles started drifting into the background again. This was EXACTLY what the anti “Lights On” campaigners said would happen and they were sadly proven to be correct. Deaths and injuries started to climb again as the novelty of noticing motorcycles with headlights on wore off.

Fast forward to 2014. Deaths and injuries from motorcycle accidents are the lowest that they have been for years. Does this mean that “Lights On” has worked? No, far from it. These excellent results are as a result of the factors I have mentioned above and bear no relation to whether a motorcycle has its headlight on or not. In proportion to the overall deaths and injuries figures on Australian roads, motorcycling death and injury statistics are still alarmingly high.

Now, a little diversion for a moment. Stick with me here, it will become clear. How many of my readers are required to wear Hi-Vis clothing at work these days? It seems that, everywhere you look there is someone with a hideous green or yellow jacket on. I’ve been noticing it more and more. Proponents of Hi-Vis will tell me that that is a good thing. Making people more visible will keep them safer in the workplace. Why, my local motorcycle licensing authority makes all learner riders undergoing road testing wear a Hi-Vis vest over their riding gear so that they are more visible on the road.

The problem? The bureaucrats have fallen for the same simplistic trap that they fell for all those years ago. Making someone/something more visible only works for a little while. Once the novelty wears off and you’ve noticed it for a while, it starts to drift into the background because everyone is doing it and they become indistinguishable from the rest.

It should come as no surprise, then, to anyone who is a student of how governments and their bureaucracies work to know that the latest suggestion is that motorcyclists be required to wear Hi-Vis clothing when riding a bike on the road. “But it will make you more visible; it will reduce the number of accidents; it’s GOOD for you.”

My dad again. “The three greatest lies in the world are: Of course I’ll respect you in the morning: The cheque’s in the mail: We’re from the government and we’re here to help you.”

Of one thing you may be sure. The LAST thing a government, of whatever political persuasion, wants to do is help you. They want to make money out of you, they want to keep you under control and they want to get re-elected. And, to that end, they will do whatever is politically expedient, even pass totally unjust laws if they think the populace will find them palatable (witness the fiasco in Queensland at the moment).

We must resist the Hi-Vis agenda. History has proven that such measures only have a short-term benefit before the status quo returns. The only people they will benefit are the politicians who frame the stupid laws to start with, the bureaucrats who get rich from enforcing the laws and the careless motorists who will continue to use the SMIDSY (Sorry, Mate I Didn’t See You) defence.

None of these measures address the underlying problem of motorcycle deaths and injuries. Instead of EDUCATING road users to LOOK OUT for motorcycles (yes, I know this is starting to happen, and not before time), the motorcyclist is being faced with increasing impositions by governments to ensure their OWN safety while allowing other road users to continue to use the SMIDSY defence. The fact that a car hits you because the driver didn’t see you should NOT be seen to be your fault. If you were taking all reasonable care, then the careless motorists cannot hide behind SMIDSY.

“Lights On”? It didn’t work. Hi-Vis? It won’t work. SMIDSY? It is alive and well and showing no signs of going away anytime soon.

Dickies Hi-Vis jacket MRAACT SMIDSY Sticker

Tags: Hi-VisMotorcyclePhil HallSafetySMIDSY
Previous Post

McGuinness to carry #1 plate; TT field firms up

Next Post

Daytona AMA SBK Recap

Trev

Trev

Motojourno - Founder of MCNews.com.au - Australia's leading resource for motorcycle news, reviews and race coverage for over 20 years.

Related Articles

Steve Trinder with his fairings still intact - Hume Weir, 1976

The Harvie Wiltshire Trophy | With Phil Hall

March 16, 2017
Dodging the bullet, near misses. With Phil Hall

Dodging the Bullet with Phil Hall

March 8, 2017
Shadowfax Oran Park

Shadowfax – What goes around… | With Phil Hall

March 3, 2017
Jarno Saarinen - Global Yamaha

Jarno Saarinen and Finland

February 28, 2017
For 2017 a DC charger socket added and the engine was updated to EURO4 compliance.

A Very Fine Ride – the VFR750 | With Phil Hall

February 20, 2017
Ralph Hudson

The Fastest of them All | Ralph Hudson | With Phil Hall

February 16, 2017
Load More
Next Post
AMA Superbike Daytona

Daytona AMA SBK Recap

Daniel Milner. Milner steps up from the E1 class (under 250cc) up to the premier E2 (450cc bikes) category after a hugely successful 2013 season. Testing has gone extremely well for Milner and he is no stranger to the bigger capacity bike having shocked the world at the ISDE last year with a stunning second place finish on the YZ450F.

Teams preview Bulahdelah AORC season opener

“I hated you all”, Leisky stated, Dack thinks "yeah that’s right."

Mr Motocross Legends and Stars Dinner

SOCIALS

  • 20.1k Fans
  • 6.6k Followers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Removeable battery packs will add great versatility to both personal consumers and fleet buyers

Honda, KTM, Piaggio and Yamaha join forces towards common swappable EV batteries

March 1, 2021
Gallery A from Winton ASBK Testing

Reflections on the state of play in ASBK after Winton two-day test

March 2, 2021
Images from Wakefield Park ASBK finale | Gallery D

ASBK Supersport Champ Tom Toparis out for season 2021

February 26, 2021
Petronas SRT MotoGP Launch – Rossi in his new colours

Petronas SRT MotoGP Launch – Rossi in his new colours

March 1, 2021
Fausto Gresini passes away after long battle with COVID

Fausto Gresini passes away after long battle with COVID

February 23, 2021
Petronas SRT MotoGP Launch – Rossi in his new colours

Petronas SRT MotoGP Launch – Rossi in his new colours

Removeable battery packs will add great versatility to both personal consumers and fleet buyers

Honda, KTM, Piaggio and Yamaha join forces towards common swappable EV batteries

Vespa GTS Super Sport 300 HPE lands in Australia

Vespa GTS Super Sport 300 HPE lands in Australia

2021 Ducati Scrambler Nightshift Review

2021 Ducati Scrambler Nightshift Review

Ryan Dungey grabs his first 450SX Class win of the season - Photo Credit: Simon Cudby

American Motocross of Nations squad

Royal Enfield Interceptor Continental GT Scene

Royal Enfield gaining strength in Australia

March 3, 2021
BMW R nineT range heavily revamped for 2021

BMW R 18 Classic Aussie pricing announced

March 3, 2021
Gallery A from Winton ASBK Testing

Gallery A from Winton ASBK Testing

March 3, 2021
Five TFX-2 waterproof gloves

Five’s winter waterproof TFX-2 gloves | $179.95

March 3, 2021
Gallery A from Winton ASBK Testing

Reflections on the state of play in ASBK after Winton two-day test

March 2, 2021

SUPPORT OUR SUPPORTERS

INCASE YOU MISSED

  • All
  • Bike Reviews
  • Motorcycle Racing
  • Latest Bikes
  • Features
  • Motorcycle Gallery
  • Touring
Removeable battery packs will add great versatility to both personal consumers and fleet buyers

Honda, KTM, Piaggio and Yamaha join forces towards common swappable EV batteries

March 1, 2021
2021 Ducati Scrambler Nightshift Review

2021 Ducati Scrambler Nightshift Review

February 26, 2021
Gallery A from Winton ASBK Testing

Reflections on the state of play in ASBK after Winton two-day test

March 2, 2021

GET LATEST NEWS IN YOUR INBOX

Motorcycle News, Sport and Reviews

MCNEWS.COM.AU is a specialist on-line resource that provides motorcycle news for motorcyclists. MCNews covers all areas of interest for the motorcycling public including news, reviews and comprehensive racing coverage.

Support MCNews

© 2021 MCNews

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • ALL NEWS
    • ALL NEWS CONDENSED
    • BMW News
    • Honda News
    • Husqvarna News
    • KTM News
    • Suzuki News
    • Yamaha News
    • Triumph News
    • Ducati News
    • Moto Guzzi News
    • Royal Enfield News
    • Kawasaki News
    • Aprilia News
    • Harley News
    • Indian News
    • MV Agusta News
    • Benelli News
    • Gas Gas News
    • BETA News
    • Norton News
    • Victory News
    • EBR News
    • E-Bike News
    • Scooter News
    • LAMS News
    • ATV / SSV News
  • REVIEWS
    • All Bike Reviews
    • LAMS Reviews
    • KTM Reviews
    • Honda Reviews
    • Yamaha Reviews
    • Triumph Reviews
    • BMW Reviews
    • Suzuki Reviews
    • Ducati Reviews
    • Kawasaki Reviews
    • Husqvarna Reviews
    • Aprilia Reviews
    • Benelli Reviews
    • BETA Reviews
    • CFMoto Reviews
    • E-Bike Reviews
    • EBR Reviews
    • Gas Gas Reviews
    • Harley Reviews
    • Indian Reviews
    • Kymco Reviews
    • Moto Guzzi Reviews
    • MV Agusta Reviews
    • Norton Reviews
    • Royal Enfield Reviews
    • Scooter Reviews
    • Sherco Reviews
    • Victory Reviews
  • LATEST BIKES
    • ALL LATEST BIKES NEWS
    • BMW
    • Honda
    • Husqvarna
    • KTM
    • Suzuki
    • Yamaha
    • Triumph
    • Ducati
    • Moto Guzzi
    • Royal Enfield
    • Kawasaki
    • Aprilia
    • Harley
    • Indian
    • MV Agusta
    • Benelli
    • Gas Gas
    • BETA
    • Norton
    • Victory
    • E-Bike
    • Scooters
    • LAMS
  • RACING
    • ALL RACING
    • ROAD
      • MotoGP
      • WSBK
      • ASBK
      • BSB
      • Real Road / TT
      • Historic Road Racing
      • Japan / Asian Road Racing
      • Endurance Road Racing
      • American Road Racing
      • NZ Road Racing
      • Supermoto
    • DIRT
      • Supercross
      • AMA MX
      • Australian MX
      • MXGP
      • Enduro / Rally
      • Dirt / Flat Track
      • Speedway
  • FEATURES
  • TOURING
  • GALLERY
  • LATEST COMMENTS
  • POPULAR ARTICLES
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT US
  • COMMUNITY FORUM

© 2021 MCNews