Thursday, July 7, 2022
MCNews
  • NEWSLatest
  • REVIEWS
  • LATEST BIKES
  • RACING
  • FEATURES
  • TOURING
  • PRODUCTS
  • MEDIA
    • GALLERY
  • MORE
    • POPULAR ARTICLES
    • MCNEWS COMMENTS
    • MAIN FORUM
    • CONTACT US
    • ABOUT US
No Result
View All Result
MCNews
  • NEWSLatest
  • REVIEWS
  • LATEST BIKES
  • RACING
  • FEATURES
  • TOURING
  • PRODUCTS
  • MEDIA
    • GALLERY
  • MORE
    • POPULAR ARTICLES
    • MCNEWS COMMENTS
    • MAIN FORUM
    • CONTACT US
    • ABOUT US
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
MCNews

Boredom by design

Trev by Trev
May 19, 2016
in MotoGP, Motorcycle News, Motorcycle Racing, WSBK
A A
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare

Boredom by design

Phil Hall has a rant about modern road race circuit layouts

I long ago gave up watching Formula 1. It has degenerated so far from the glory days of Clark, Hill, Brabham and the others who were my idols as a youth that I cannot bear to watch what crimes are now being commited in its name. F1 is, in my opinion, glorified slot cars with drivers who are more concerned with fuel consumption than speed and cars that sound like an asthmatic who is gasping for his last breath.

However, it still has its followers (God knows why) and it still continues to go looking even further afield to bolster its already obscenely overflowing coffers. Despite the downturn in the economy of many countries, Bernie and his minions (!) continue to compile the list of new, and proposed circuits in far-flung (and often ridiculous) places. Unfortunately, they all have one thing in common……THEY ARE BORING.

There is a reason for this. Circuits like the Yas Marina circuit in Dubai and Circuit of the Americas in Austin, Texas (only the Americans could concoct such a pretentious name) have one thing in common. They are all designed by the boring German, Hermann Tilke. And  the overwheling characteristic of a Tilke-designed layout is a complete and utter lack of high-speed corners. They are all “made for television” layouts where a preponderance of slow, stop/start corners artificially keep the pack together and make it look (at least to the uninitiated) as if exciting racing is taking place.

There are two constituencies who must be satisfied if one is to provide a racing circuit. The competitors have to like it and the spectators have to like it. Now it’s fair to say that competitors will race ANYWHERE because, in the end, that’s their passion. It’s also often their pay cheque so the old, “If you build it, they will come” mantra is pretty true. Satisfying spectators is a different matter and, with safety precautions becoming more and more stringent, the poor spectator is being squeezed out of the equation as well. It is not surprising that the TV broadcasts show many overseas races taking place in front of empty or near-empty stands.

Now a V8 Taxi event took place at the Yas Marina circuit a while ago and the circuit was described by James Courtney, one of the drivers at that event, as “lacking character”. I’m sure if James hadn’t been constrained by the usual media muzzle through which drivers must speak these days, he’d have said that “It’s boring as bats**t”

Yas Marina
Yas Marina

I invite you to compare the circuit maps of the two latest tracks under discussion here. The similarity is eerie. So, why has COTA met with (slightly) better approval ratings than the Dubai layout? It’s pretty simple. Despite the total lack of high speed corners, COTA has the advantage that it has substantial elevation changes which do give the track some character. If it had been built on a flat piece of ground it wouldn’t have been half as entertaining and engaging for competitors and would be almost the same.

So at least COTA has some elevation changes, but, again, WHERE ARE THE HIGH-SPEED CORNERS?

Circuit of The Americas
Circuit of The Americas

What makes Monza, Spa, Estoril, Hockenheim (the old one, not the new abortionate travesty), Assen, (see above), what makes these tracks iconic and wonderful? Answer, high-speed corners. It’s not rocket science. As James Courtney said, these days the spectators are placed 1000kms away from the track and all they can see is a few, stop/start corners.

“But that makes for better TV,” say the apologists and TV is where the money is. Bugger the poor spectators who pay their money at the gate; they don’t matter. Did I read some time ago that there is a new horse racing facility that has been built in the USA that has NO spectator facilities at ALL? I’m sure I did. The racing is televised and people watch it on their screens at home or down at the pub. It’s sure cheaper for the promoter and absolves them of the responsibility of providing a good spectacle for the people in the stands.

Look at the list of Tilke-designed circuits and compare them. They’re all “cookie cutter” layouts, designed for television with spectators and competitors needs and wants coming second. Now there is no doubt that the COTA MotoGp races are a great spectacle on the small screen, but so they should be because that is what the purpose of the circuit design was.

RelatedPosts

Steve Trinder with his fairings still intact - Hume Weir, 1976

The Harvie Wiltshire Trophy | With Phil Hall

March 16, 2017
Dodging the bullet, near misses. With Phil Hall

Dodging the Bullet with Phil Hall

March 8, 2017

What separates the good riders from the great riders? Is it the ability to perform a flawless block pass into a second gear corner? Of course it’s not. It’s the ability to keep it wired through a flat out corner and not flinch. The trouble is that there are very few such opportunities available. This one of the many reasons why I miss Bathurst and, to a lesser extent, Oran Park.

The defining moment of the 1996 F1 World Championship was when Jacques Villeneuve passed Michael Schumacher around the OUTSIDE of the Parabolica Corner at Estoril, a high-speed, heart-in-mouth pass that people still talk about today. Find it on Youtube and  watch and enjoy because soon all the high-speed corners will be gone and daring like this will have slipped into history.

I sincerely hope that the designers of the newly proposed circuits here in Australia, Wagga, Shoalhaven, Tailem Bend, etc, heed the cries from both competitors and spectators alike to put back some breathtaking into their circuits. We certainly need it.

For God’s sake, let’s have some high-speed corners.

Tags: Phil Hall
Trev

Trev

Motojourno - Founder of MCNews.com.au - Australia's leading resource for motorcycle news, reviews and race coverage for over 20 years.

Related Articles

All category round up from MotoGP Dutch TT at Assen

More MotoGP rule changes announced

July 7, 2022
Crossing the Simpson Desert by Motorcycle: Part 1 Prep

Crossing the Simpson: Part 5 – Birdsville then heading home

July 7, 2022
Tony Cairoli flying high at Hangtown

Tony Cairoli reflects on AMA Pro Motocross campaign

July 7, 2022
WorldSBK Teams test at Navarra, a new stop on the 2021 calendar

A look inside at how the KRT WorldSBK pit garage works

July 7, 2022
Load More

SOCIALS

  • 7.2k Followers

SUPPORT OUR SUPPORTERS

INCASE YOU MISSED

AFT Singles Start at the 2022 New York Short Track - Image by Kristen Lassen

Moto News | WSX | MX | Enduro | Flat Track | Long Track

July 5, 2022
Benelli Leoncino + BONUS Pannier Kit!🔥

Benelli Leoncino + BONUS Pannier Kit!🔥

July 5, 2022
TC Max Back in Stock + BONUS Fast Charger⚡

TC Max Back in Stock + BONUS Fast Charger⚡

July 6, 2022

GET LATEST NEWS IN YOUR INBOX

MCNews

MCNEWS.COM.AU is a specialist on-line resource that provides motorcycle news for motorcyclists. MCNews covers all areas of interest for the motorcycling public including news, reviews and comprehensive racing coverage.

© 2022 MCNews

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • ALL NEWS
    • ALL NEWS CONDENSED
    • POPULAR ARTICLES
    • BMW News
    • Honda News
    • Husqvarna News
    • KTM News
    • Suzuki News
    • Yamaha News
    • Triumph News
    • CFMOTO News
    • Ducati News
    • Moto Guzzi News
    • Royal Enfield News
    • Kawasaki News
    • Aprilia News
    • Harley News
    • Indian News
    • MV Agusta News
    • Benelli News
    • GASGAS News
    • BETA News
    • Norton News
    • Victory News
    • EBR News
    • Rieju News
    • E-Bike News
    • Scooter News
    • LAMS News
    • ATV / SSV News
  • REVIEWS
    • All Bike Reviews
    • LAMS Reviews
    • KTM Reviews
    • Honda Reviews
    • Yamaha Reviews
    • Triumph Reviews
    • BMW Reviews
    • Suzuki Reviews
    • CFMOTO Reviews
    • Ducati Reviews
    • Kawasaki Reviews
    • Husqvarna Reviews
    • Aprilia Reviews
    • Benelli Reviews
    • BETA Reviews
    • E-Bike Reviews
    • EBR Reviews
    • GAS GAS Reviews
    • Harley Reviews
    • Indian Reviews
    • Kymco Reviews
    • Moto Guzzi Reviews
    • MV Agusta Reviews
    • Norton Reviews
    • Royal Enfield Reviews
    • Scooter Reviews
    • Sherco Reviews
    • Victory Reviews
    • Rieju Reviews
  • NEW PRODUCTS
  • LATEST BIKES
    • ALL LATEST BIKES NEWS
    • BMW
    • Honda
    • Husqvarna
    • KTM
    • Suzuki
    • Yamaha
    • Triumph
    • CFMOTO
    • Ducati
    • Moto Guzzi
    • Royal Enfield
    • Kawasaki
    • Aprilia
    • Harley
    • Indian
    • MV Agusta
    • Benelli
    • GAS GAS
    • BETA
    • Norton
    • Victory
    • E-Bike
    • Scooters
    • LAMS
    • Rieju
  • RACING
    • ALL RACING
    • ROAD
      • MotoGP
      • WSBK
      • ASBK
      • BSB
      • Real Road / TT
      • Historic Road Racing
      • Japan / Asian Road Racing
      • Endurance Road Racing
      • American Road Racing
      • NZ Road Racing
      • Supermoto
      • FIM Junior GP & MiniGP
    • DIRT
      • Supercross
      • AMA MX
      • Australian Pro MX
      • MXGP
      • Enduro / Rally
      • Dirt / Flat Track
      • Speedway
  • FEATURES
  • TOURING
  • GALLERY
  • LATEST COMMENTS
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT US
  • COMMUNITY FORUM

© 2022 MCNews